Talk:Accelerator/@comment-24.189.129.106-20141229203327/@comment-14.162.24.174-20150201184149

Thank you very much for your thorough answer, Kamina; I completely understand how Accel cannot teleport now :) There's a few points that I would like to raise though. Please feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, because I understand that my understanding of the To aru universe may not be that great. With all due respect, here goes:

1) About whether Electromasters can really generate electricity like you said:

If I understand correctly, from Komoe's conversation with Index and Himegami in vol 3 (when she explained to them about the nature of espers' power and quantum theory), Komoe said that what espers do is essentially using their personal reality to cause microscopic changes in the world. To be more specific, she gave an example of the hard candy and the chocolate and how the normal probability of getting either one of those 2 from a closed box is 50%, but with an esper, they can manipulate the probability so that it can be 100% hard candy or 100% chocolate. However, she also added in that the probability of something that cannot happen (like getting a gum from the box) is still 0%. What I get from these explainations was that espers cannot do what has no chance of occuring in the first place. So to say that an electromaster can "generate" electricity sounds a bit contradictory for me, because as we all know, electricity is the movement of electron, and if there is no electron, there can be no electricity. Therefore, saying that electromasters can create electricity out of nothing seems totally weird, unless they can create electrons out of nothing. Thus, in my opinion, an electromaster cannot "generate" electricity in an environment devoid of any electron (which, I understand, is hard to occur in nature), but he/she merely control the electrons in the environment around them to create a lightning/spark/ ... I believe that Accel can mimic this ability down to every little application if this is the case, with the only difference is that he needs to make contact with the electrons in order to manipulate them, when electromasters like Misaka can just manipulate electrons from afar.

2) About Dark matter:

Yes, this is the one ability that I can't understand, especially with Komoe's explaination about quantum theory as stated above, because it seems that Kakine can indeed "create" something out of nothing. These new matters shouldn't be able to exist in the universe in the first place, because the chance of them occuring in nature is 0% (in the novel, it's stated that Dark matters are matters that do not exist anywhere in the universe until Kakine creates them, if I recall correctly). However, perhaps I can brush this off because it's been mentioned many times in the novel that his ability of "creating" is in direct contrast to Accel's ability of "destroying" and both of their territory have "touched the territory of god" or is "the power of god" (if I recall correctly, again). So, maybe it made sense that they may do what normal espers cannot do, and can somehow bypass the possibility law. So it perhaps only makes sense that Accel cannot mimic Kakine's ability of "creating" simply because Kakine's ability is a special case.

If what I said above is correct, then perhaps these 2 cannot be used as examples for how Accel cannot mimic the effects of other abilities. Now, I understand the case about Teleport, since 1) Teleporters only calculate vectors, not manipulate them; and 2) Accel cannot interact with the 11th dimension. However, what I want to say is that it's probably a bit too hasty to conclude that the application of Accel's power (not Accel's power itself) cannot fully mimic other abilities 100%.

Once again, I don't mean to nitpick your answer or anything, I'm just a bit curious about whether my understanding about To aru is correct. All I want is to have a meaningful discussion about this matter and increase my knowledge.

Regards :)