Thread:TheGreatEye/@comment-7694700-20130619121447/@comment-1967894-20130627035455

Dniv wrote: I'm not sure about this because there is a slight danger of non-objectivity; however, I know for example, that the evangelion wiki or that there is one somewhere maybe not in wikia that provids analysis of philosophical themes and quotations and events. Do you think we could improve the quote pages by pointing some things out about what they are referencing/ representing in the context of the light novels. I feel like a lot of us like to put some of the important quotes that sound cool in the writing, but most of the people reading them don't understand why they are so important or what they are either hinting at or what they mean. So I feel like this might be a good idea. However, since there is a danger of personal opinion in analyzing quotes in this way when you are talking about more than just the context of the quotes, you might find this destructive or unnecessary as an addition. What do you think about doing this? I think it would be cool to look at/ or analyze the different ideas Kamachi brings up throughout the light novels. Not just in quotes, but with relation to every time Touma, Mikoto, Accelerator or someone else have an ideological face-off and end up "growing up" from the encounter/battle once they win it. I definitely think it would be nice to have something like that, but since it could of course be biased, I'm not sure how you would feel about it. Maybe that type of stuff would be better for a blog sort of thing... but I feel like since we don't have that many people on the wiki, it could be a better way to get people interested in it. I was wondering what you thought. Thanks.

Analysis, personal opinions, and reviews of the themes and symbolism of the series should be confined to the blogs. Unless it is a proper critic or expert of note, though I doubt there is someone who would consider Index as a great literature needing of analysis like that of Catcher in the Rye, but I digress.