Talk:Index Librorum Prohibitorum/@comment-95.90.111.118-20140511224703/@comment-11571396-20140514043843

Seriously, every time I type in A Certain Magical Index, I ALWAYS bump into a page about Mikoto Misaka which is the front page of the article.

And that is proof that anyone loves Misaka? No. First, it's an anecdote from you so it's neither trustworthy, nor does it mean that other people arrive at the same results. Second, it could just mean that said pages are the most accessed pages, which doesn't mean anything about why the Internet user clicked on it.

Seriously, even mere anime-analysts, like JesuOtaku and ShadowACS that haven't even heard ACMI before are all out fans of Misaka

Not only have I never heard of them, nor do I care about them, but this is a clear appeal to authority: some known person like this, so obviously it is good. Your reviewers are not representative of any population, anime viewers or anyone, so no, they are not a good example. Anime reviewers =/= anyone.

Because of how original her backstory

...there is nothing original about Mikoto's backstory. Like, at all. She comes from a happy family, even if they are a bit rich; she was sent to Academy City at a young age (like everyone else); she likes a frog mascot; she is a Level 5 (like 6 others, so it's not like she's unique); she has power over electromagnetism.

Her backstory is interesting, but less than other characters, and there is nothing particularily original about it.

is and the "completely natural" relationship with her and Touma.

Tsundere hitting guy she likes. Oh yeah, "completely natural" relationship (sarcasm).

Even people that absolutely hate the anime (which is only about 3% of anime fans) have stated that Misaka is the complete exception to all of this "pile of crap of a show".

Did you conduct a study or a peer reviewed research to pull those numbers and statements out of your ass?

You should really see their anime analysis on ACMI and you'll see what I mean.

Don't care about their opinions. They do not support your claim that "anyone who is anyone" LOVES Railgun, if anything, it seems to showcase that you seem to suffer from a serious case of confirmation bias.