Talk:Index Librorum Prohibitorum/@comment-113.172.68.156-20140315154508/@comment-11571396-20140326231557

ACSR = A Certain Scientific Railgun. I don't even get why people put it in acronym, just writting Railgun is enough, and less confusing for everyone else.

Moving on, it's too early to make an opinion about Accelerator manga compared to the other 2, but it is promising. However, the Index manga is mediocre IMO, it edits out a lot of stuff from the LNs (to the point it could be called an alternate universe), and is just plain boring to be honest. Railgun manga is good, really good even for a (strictly speaking) scifi manga. Its anime however is a letdown, save for certain parts, it doesn't compare to the original material (and the less is said about cloverfield, the better)

Railgun manga > Index manga

Railgun manga > Railgun anime

Index LNs > everything else