Talk:Imagine Breaker/@comment-173.166.15.157-20141215154056/@comment-5230978-20141217012907

Yes it is similar but could be both

What could be both? And both what? Do you mean Psionisc being both magical and scientifical? But IB belongs to none of these side so that cant be an explanation.

I have also stated before "he can't control imagine breaker in other words his subconscious could be controlling it" Basically what I mean is his subconscious could be "The Will Of Imagine Breaker"

It seems you are mistaking IB for Touma's power but it's not. IB is a host-changing power and Touma is the actual host, so if IB has a will it is unrelated to Touma and his subconscious. Look, IB was still active even after Fiamma cut Touma's right arm, disassembled, and absorbed it in his Third Arm, and when Othinus destroyed Touma's right wrist IB reattached to Touma by itself whilw he was unconscious. These are clear examples that IB is a passive ability, that seemingly have some active aspects, but that surely is not subconsciously controlled by Touma.

also the fact that there is no other Psionic ability in To Aru might be what makes Imagine Breaker unique

Sorry, but your psionic is something you brought form other series which existence was never mentioned or implied in Toaru. Using you reasoning anyone could bring terms form other series (e.g. ki, chakra, nen), make up a fantasy and try to apply it to IB. And again, psionics is a (pseudo)scientifical concept so if it existed in Toaru it would be scientifical or applied to espers as psionics is the effect of psychic abilities using the mind.

I realize that a Soul is more of a magical concept

I didn't express myself well in my previosu post. In Toaru, the soul is just another name for life force and when refined it becomes magic power. Normal soul is just life force like that of any other human and simply having it doesn't give powers or control on them, and when refined it becomes magic power, so not even soul is an explanation.

but it can be explained with science it becomes magical when you apply something like abilities from Soul Eater or Bleach

First of all, Toaru science can't explain sould at all. Secondly, applying rules of other series is absurd. Only because a concept is treated in a certain way in a series it doesn't mean it is even in otherd (e.g. in Naruto ninjas use ninjutsus and genjutsus but it doesn't mean that Toaru ninjas can do the same). And the science of the series you mentioned is specialized in souls as the series are based on souls and differently from them Toaru science is moslty based on physics.